| Class of 2020 | | | | | |
| Player | Position | | | | College |
| Dawson Browning | Midfield | | | | IB; University of Florida; 2020 Lacrosse All Star Alternate |
| Chase Dexter | Midfield | | | | Firefighting School |
| Jordan Foltz | Midfield | | | | University of South Florida; 2x Lombardo Nease Award Winner |
| Noah Lee | Midfield | | | | Undecided |
| Matthew Pounder | D/LSM | | | | Jacksonville University (D1); 2020 Florida Coaches Association (FSCLA) All-State Team and 2020 Lacrosse All-Star, 3 x All County, 2 x Nease HS Team MVP |
| Emerick Wurstner | Defense | | | | Enlisted in the US Marine Corps |
| | | | | | |
| Class of 2019 | | | | | |
| Player | Position | | | | College |
| Tucker Albritton | Defense | | | | Florida State University; FSLCA Top 44 Senior Game |
| Peyton Brocksmith | Defense | | | | Florida State University |
| Jacob Gmeiner | Attack | | | | University of South Carolina; ROTC |
| Gavin Hembach | Midfield / FOGO | | | | Florida State University |
| Zack Hunt | Midfield | | | | University of South Florida; Nursing |
| Reilly Mickey | Midfield | | | | Undecided |
| Ben Mylet | Defense | | | | Penn State University |
| Noah Soleim | Midfield | | | | Florida State University |
| | | | | | |
| Class of 2018 | | | | |
| Player | | | Position | | | | College |
| Ashton Wood | | | Midfield / FOGO | | | | Mercer University (D1); 1st Team All-County; All-County Player of the Year; US Lacrosse All American; 2 x Nease HS Team MVP |
| Billy Delarm | | | Midfield / FOGO | | | | Methodist University (D3) |
| Joey Pappaceno | | | Goalie | | | | Florida Southern University (D2); 2nd Team All-County |
| Zack Ott | | | Attack | | | | UCF (Club); 2nd Team All-County |
| Grant Kettering | | | Midfield | | | | UCF (Club) |
| Phil Mylet | | | Attack | | | | Florida (Club); US Lacrosse All American, 1st Team All-County |
| Hunter Kobin | | | Attack | | | | Elon University; 6th Leading Scorer in Nease HS History |
| Alec Regan | | | Attack | | | | UNF |
| Hunter Paulsen | | | Midfield | | | | Enlisted in US Army |
| Jesse Gatewood | | | Midfield | | | | Embry Riddle |
| Ryan Kirk | | | Defense | | | | UNF |
| Jared Graham | | | Defense | | | | SJR; 2nd Team All-County |
Matt Olkiewicz
| | | Midfield | | | | Clemson University; 2nd Team All-County |
| | | | | | | | |
| Class of 2017 | | | | |
| Player | | | Position | | | | College |
| Mason Combs | | | Defense | | | | University of Montevallo (D2); 2nd Team All-County |
| Kyle Cronk | | | Midfield | | | | Hampton Sydney (D3) |
| Nick Eichorn | | | Defense | | | | UNF |
| Kirean McKee | | | Midfield | | | | Clemson |
| Tyler Schaffer | | | Defense | | | | Transfer to UF (Club); 1st Team All-County |
| Reid Whiting | | | Midfield | | | | UF |
| Chris Gilmer | | | Midfield | | | | Embry Riddle |
| | | | | | | | |
| Class of 2016 | | | | |
| Player |
|
|
Position |
|
|
|
College |
| Ian Areford |
|
|
Goalie |
|
|
|
St. Leo (D2); Academic All-American; 1st Team All-County |
| Richard Caserta |
|
|
Midfield |
|
|
|
Florida Institute of Technology |
| Michael Cotter |
|
|
Midfield |
|
|
|
FSU |
| Joey Oliveira |
|
|
Midfield |
|
|
|
FSU; 2nd Team All-County |
| Austin Prince |
|
|
Long-Stick Midfield (LSM) |
|
|
|
Transfer to UF (Club); 2nd Team All-County |
| Bobby Roberts |
|
|
Attack |
|
|
|
Jacksonville University |
| Brent Whiting |
|
|
Attack |
|
|
|
UF; 4th Leading Scorer in Nease HS History |